I've been mulling over the apparent shortcomings of our federal government, and a couple possible constitutional amendments have come to mind.
One of the issues is that of gerrymandering. The re-election rate for incumbent members of Congress is over 90%. State legislatures draw districts in very partisan ways. I recall a Reader's Digest article on gerrymandering that described a district that stretched in six long narrow psuedopods across half the state, and another that was two residential districts connected by several miles of interstate highway. Somebody tried to get a district that was actually two areas completely separated from each other, but courts shot that down.
My proposed correction: "1. Congressional districts shall be drawn so that each can be enclosed within a rectangle with an area no more than 120% of the area of the district. 2. If the geography and population distribution of a state make doing so impossible, then congressional districts of that state shall be drawn to minimize the total area of rectangles enclosing all congressional districts. 3. States with only one district shall be exempt. 4. A rectangle shall be a geometric figure with four sides and four equal vertices."
A second issue is that the states have been rendered subservient to the federal government, which was never the intention of the Founders who wrote the Constitution. That was the original function of the Senate, to give the States a voice in the legislative process. A third is that getting rid of bad laws is far more difficult than it ought to be. As James Madison warned us, ""It will be of little avail to the people, that the laws are made by men of their own choice, if the laws be so voluminous that they cannot be read, or so incoherent that they cannot be understood; if they be repealed or revised before they are promulgated, or undergo such incessant changes that no man, who knows what the law is today, can guess what it will be to-morrow." To correct these, I propose the following amendment:
"1. The House of Relief is hereby established. 2. Members of the House of Relief shall be called Relievers. 3. The legislatures of each State shall appoint three Relievers, who shall serve at the pleasure of their respective state legislatures, which may recall or replace them at any time, and for any reason, or for no reason at all. 4. The House of Relief shall only have the power to pass bills that repeal federal laws and regulations of the United States, and to terminate federal departments and offices not established by the Constitution of the United States. 5. Any such bill which receives votes of one-third of Relievers currently in office shall be passed to the President of the United States without review by the other houses of Congress, and will become law upon his signature, or fail if the President should veto the bill. 6. Any bill which receives votes of one-half of all Relievers currently in office shall become law immediately, overriding any Presidential veto, without review by any other branch of government."
While I think these are more-or-less good ideas, I'm sure they could use some polish. Any ideas anyone may have for their refinement would be most welcome.
No comments:
Post a Comment